Building quotes differ because contractors may price different scopes, materials, labour assumptions, overheads, risks and exclusions. A lower total does not necessarily represent better value. Compare quotations against the same drawings and specifications, then establish the likely total cost of completing the project.
Check whether the scope is identical
Give each tenderer the same current drawings, schedules and written requirements. Ask for clarification of omissions and alternatives. One contractor may include excavation, rubble removal and painting while another prices only the main building work. A quotation based on an earlier drawing revision may not reflect the final design.
Compare allowances and exclusions
Provisional sums and prime cost amounts can make prices appear comparable when their underlying assumptions differ. Check the intended finish quality, quantities and treatment of specialist work. Confirm whether temporary services, site security, scaffolding, testing and handover documents are included. Obtain separate prices for excluded work.
Worked example: comparing two quotes
| Illustrative cost | Quote A | Quote B |
|---|---|---|
| Quoted total | R850,000 | R930,000 |
| External works excluded | R60,000 | R0 |
| Finishes allowance adjustment | R35,000 | R0 |
| Comparable estimated total | R945,000 | R930,000 |
All figures are hypothetical and assumed to include applicable VAT consistently. Quote A initially appears R80,000 cheaper, but after adjusting the scope it is R15,000 higher. Obtain actual written prices for the missing items rather than relying on guesses.
Why contractor rates vary
Different firms have different staffing, equipment, purchasing arrangements and workloads. A contractor with a nearby team may incur less travel cost than one mobilising from another region. Site access, construction sequence and payment terms also influence pricing. The BER Building Cost Index provides context on tender-price movements, not a definitive rate for your project.
Evaluate more than price
Check relevant experience, references, insurance, capacity and applicable registrations. For regulated home building work, confirm the applicable NHBRC requirements with the National Home Builders Registration Council. Review the contract, payment milestones, completion date, variation procedures and defects obligations before signing. A quantity surveyor can assist with tender comparison on larger or complex projects.
Use our house building cost calculator to establish a preliminary budget and browse construction contractors when seeking comparable quotations.
Frequently asked questions
No. Compare equivalent scope, competence, risk, contract terms and likely final cost.
Confirm VAT registration and whether the quoted amount includes applicable VAT. Compare the actual amount payable.
The answer depends on the agreed terms, authorised variations and applicable law. Review the price adjustment provisions.
Related construction questions
- What costs are often excluded from a house building quote?
- What is a prime cost allowance?
- What is the difference between an estimate and a quotation?
Have More Construction Questions?
Explore our South African construction knowledge hub for practical answers about building materials, costs, regulations, construction methods and more.
Browse All Construction Questions